A: Without a doubt! WebKirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is made from winter harvest organic seaweed and is sesame flavored. Please download the PDF to view it: Download PDF. Winter harvest Is this really true?! Top Pick Chosen. Kirkland Organic Raw Whole Cashews Unsalted Unroasted, 40 oz. United States(expand to select country/region), Type and press the down arrow to browse search suggestions, Use product only as directed. WebKirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed, 0.6 oz, 10-count USDA Organic Kosher (OU) 20 Calories per Serving Sesame Flavor Buy now Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed, 0.6 oz, 10-count | Costco 1998 2023 Costco Wholesale Corporation. The Proposition 65-listed chemicals commonly found in such foods are: A warning for acrylamide on a food product suggests that regular consumption of the food over time can pose a greater cancer risk than consumption of foods with lower acrylamide levels. According to the case, edible seaweed has been associated with improved thyroid function, gut health, immunity and cardiovascular and brain health. WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including [name of one or more chemicals], which is [are] known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. The word cancer (in brackets above) is optional, at the judgment of the manufacturer. This versatile snack can be enjoyed wrapped around rice, in your favorite soup, salad or sandwich, as a pizza topping, or simply plain. Seaweeds may help treat other types of cancer too. Please try again at a later time. All Rights Reserved. Too much iodine consumption can lead to problems very similar to iodine deficiency. New to ClassAction.org? WebOur Kirkland Signature Organic Seaweed Snacks are an addictive, savoury snack with a sesame flavour made with organic oils and sea salt. ConsumerLab.com uses JavaScript to provide the best possible experience for our content, but your browser has it disabled. Sign Up Log In Messenger Facebook Lite Watch Places Games Using our two earlier examples of laver and sea lettuce, we find their roles reversed; sea lettuce had one of the highest levels of lead detected in our products (0.6 ppm), and laver one of the lowest (0.1 ppm). A serving can be as low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled with taste and nutritional value. WebKirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz, 10-count USDA Organic Kosher (OU) 20 Calories per Serving Sesame Flavor Buy now Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz, 10-count | Costco WebKirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed, 0.6 oz, 10-count USDA Organic Kosher (OU) 20 Calories per Serving Sesame Flavor Buy now Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed, 0.6 oz, 10-count | Costco 10 Pack; Organic; Winter Harvest; Sesame Flavor; Only 20 Calories per Serving; Low Fat; Sugar Free; Cholesterol Free; Kosher; Certified Organic: Bioagricert srl. This is an exception to Costco's return policy. ConsumerLab.com name and flask logo are both registered trademarks of ConsumerLab.com, LLC. Long a staple in Asian countries, most westerners are fairly new to the sea veggie scene. According to the 40-page lawsuit, Costco knew or should have known that its seaweed product contained cadmium, a known human carcinogen associated with various health risks, yet failed to sufficiently test the snack and warn consumers of the presence of the heavy metal. Type and press the down arrow to browse search suggestions, Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 10-count. What are the Safe Harbor levels for the heavy metals cadmium, lead, and arsenic, and how do our products compare? We estimate 7-10 business days for you to be contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment. Statements regarding dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or health condition. She does caution that you can get too much iodine from taking seaweed capsules as a supplement, however. The NSRL is established as the level that would result in no more than one case of cancer out of every 100,000 individuals exposed to the chemical every day over a 70-year time frame. If you have questions about your membership or products you've purchased at Costco, please visit the membership counter at your local Costco or Collection, Springwall Comfort Pockets Breeze Mattress, Springwall Comfort Pockets Renew Mattress, Jewellery Buy Online & Pick Up in Warehouse, Costco Concierge Services | Technical Support. The single serving of nori contained in a SeaSnax roasted seaweed snack-pack contains 25 mcg of iodine, which is well within the safe zone, according to Dr. Jane Teas, a prominent researcher at the University of South Carolina. My only concern with it, kids-wise, is that its fairly salty, but it also has protein and iron, so Im comfortable with the salt in Something went wrong and we are unable to display the item price. Why is this product being sold? For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food. We dont sell hijiki and all of our sea vegetable products are low in inorganic arsenic, so none of them The amount of iodine per day that one can safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg in young children to 1,100 mcg in adults. This fee will be quoted at checkout. The Kirkland Fish Oil supplement is a product that purports to offer a wide range of health benefits with good heart health as well as blood vessels being paramount. Sign up for ClassAction.orgs free weekly newsletter here. Please include the name of your news organization when contacting us. WebKirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack Pack of 12 (0.6 oz each) Brand: Kirkland Signature 277 ratings | 11 answered questions Climate Pledge Friendly Flavor Name: Almond Diet type USDA Organic Kosher Ingredients About this item Pack of 12 Sesame flavor Winter harvest Red seaweed encompasses dulse and all types of nori, which holds our sushi rolls together and fills those snack-packs sold by Trader Joes, SeaSnax, and Marin County based GimMe Seaweed (owned by Annie Chun). The word cancer (in brackets above) is optional, at the judgment of the manufacturer. More information may be found at www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food/en/. On evolving topics, studies from pre-print journals may be sourced. 7 Comments loving1another. These Notices alleged that seaweed and seafood contain arsenic, cadmium and/or lead (and related compounds) and therefore require a Prop. The lawsuit alleges that Costcos Kirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is deceptively labeled in that it fails to disclose anywhere on the packaging that the product contains or has a significant risk of containing dangerous heavy metals such as cadmium. Look for packages stamped with the USDA certification mark or do a little research before you buy to help ensure that your seaweed will do you more good than harm. Mar 27 2018. Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 10-count Sesame flavour 
Change Delivery Postal Code, We're sorry, we are unable to determine availability. Final Verdict. (Correct answer). WebThe NSRL Safe Harbor for inorganic arsenic is 10g per day, so just gram of hijiki would cause exposure above the Safe Harbor level. We dont sell hijiki and all of our sea vegetable products are low in inorganic arsenic, so none of them require a Prop 65 warning for this element. Based on Defendants decision to wholly omit mention of the presence of cadmium, heavy metal and/or other undesirable toxins or contaminants in the Products, and to instead advertise, package, and market their Products as healthy, nutritious, and organic, claims which were bolstered by images of the seaweed snack on the packaging, they had a duty to ensure that these statements and the message portrayed by the packagings imagery were true and not misleading, the lawsuit attests. These seaweed crisps are crowd pleasers not only because of the taste, texture and low calorie count, but because we figure that eating any kind of vegetable even if its from the ocean must be good for us. We dont sell hijiki and all of our sea vegetable products are low in inorganic arsenic, so none of them I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? Seaweed also has a low calorie content (between 1 and 5 percent dry weight), which makes it a good option for dieters (5). But what do we really know about the benefits of eating seaweeds? Although some studies have shown no negative consequences from ingesting huge amounts of seaweed, others have found that it contains an excessive quantity of heavy metals, arsenic, and iodine, which might cause health problems. Want more information? This browser does not support PDFs. 
The company makes an effort to offer the consumer a money back guarantee and has adopted a world class technology in ensuring safe products reaches its consumers. The National Institutes of Health recommends no more than 1100 mcg maximum iodine intake for adults and 300 mcg for kids 4-8, while the minimum daily RDA is 150 mcg for adults and 90 mcg for 4-8 year-olds. Seaweed (at least from some bodies of water) contains naturally occurring high levels of cancer-causing substances such as arsenic, cadmium, and lead. 
A warning for acrylamide on a food product suggests that regular consumption of the food over time can pose a greater cancer risk than consumption of foods with lower acrylamide levels. 
Seaweed contains the widest spectrum of minerals of any food on the earth, with 10-20 times the mineral concentration of land plants. Scientists have tested sea vegetables from all over the world for heavy metals and other contaminants, and everywhere they consistently find that most species contain lead, cadmium, and arsenic in their tissues. . Seaweed also contains vitamin K, which could interfere with blood-thinning medications such as Warfarin. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. 
This is why some companies choose to post the warning even if their product contains listed chemicals below Safe Harbor levels. 
Change Delivery Postal Code, We're sorry, we are unable to determine availability. Mar 27 2018. As a result, items sold in states such as California may be compelled to include a warning. I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? For one thing, companies that dont market into California dont have to concern themselves with Prop 65. Obviously I wont be buying this again because I just didnt love it but if you like seaweed I would definitely check this out for a healthy snack! J&JCI 2023, Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz, 10-count. 
Some companies may not even be aware of the legal hazard due to unfamiliarity with the law or because they dont have a testing program. Among the seaweed products tested by ConsumerLab, amounts of iodine provided ranged from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested serving. Although it is decidedly a good move to add some seaweed to your dietary mix, there are a few things worth considering about the promise and safety of eating these marine greens, before you dive in. Why Cancer Labels Are Super Misleading ! When Intermittent Fasting What Snacks Can I Snack On If I Get Hungry? The one-page order granting the parties joint motion to dismiss the case, signed by United States District Judge M. James Lorenz, can be found here. As a result, items sold in states such as California may be compelled to include a warning. 
Is Cosrx AHA BHA toner good for sensitive skin? Products containing seaweed contain chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. Seaweeds can be eaten fresh from the sea, but are more often dried and then roasted or reconstituted to their original form and incorporated into soups or salads. Brown seaweeds, such as bull kelp, giant kelp, and alaria fistulosa, contain carbohydrates that cannot be digested by the human digestive system. Put another way, the MADL is the level at which a chemical would have no observable effect, even if an individual were exposed to 1,000 times that level. It is also high in protein and fiber, making it a nutritious addition to any diet. All of our content is reviewed by medical doctors and doctoral-level experts in pharmacology, toxicology, and chemistry. A lack of iodine may lead to thyroid difficulties, but so can a surplus of the mineral, she explains, noting that only a small number of North Americans are iodine deficient since our table salt is iodized. Arsenic, Cadmium and Lead in Seaweed and Seafood Products. Mar 27 2018. Seaweeds may help treat other types of cancer too. WebWARNING: Handling the cord on this product will expose you to lead, a chemical known to the State of California to cause [cancer, and] birth defects or other reproductive harm. In January 2020 alone, plaintiffs issued 14 Notices for various seaweed and seafood products including dried seaweed, dried shrimp, dried anchovies, and canned squid. Products containing seaweed contain chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. Join now to save favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews. The British Food Standards Agency published an article today advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of seaweed due to health concerns. This feature is restricted to active members. Please try again at a later time. . Like their terrestrial counterparts, sea greens can be contaminated by heavy metals such as lead and mercury lurking in the environment where they are grown. Learn how to enable it, Amounts of iodine in each product (many are very high in iodine), as well as amounts of protein, carbohydrates, calcium and sodium, Concentrations of toxic heavy metals lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury in each -- many seaweed snack labels bear a warning if concentrations exceed a certain amount but don't give exact amounts -- we do, Tips for choosing the best seaweed snacks, including one type of seaweed to avoid, Potential dangers of consuming too many servings of seaweed snacks, including effects on the thyroid, interactions with thyroid medication, blood thinners and other medications, who should avoid seaweed snacks, and symptoms of getting too much iodine. 65 warning. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. For Canadian customers only. In the full review, the newest information is highlighted in yellow and, if a new product is added, Its important to bear in mind that much more research is needed, but studies have also suggested that eating seaweed may help reduce inflammation, lower blood pressure and boost general heart health, among other benefits. 2023 ConsumerLab.com, LLC. What is the nutritional value of seaweed? Although harvested around the globe, China is responsible for nearly 60% of the worlds seaweed production. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. The reason for this warning is that I may be at risk of chemical exposure from some meals and beverages sold or provided by restaurants and other food service establishments. By design, Safe Harbors are established with very large safety margins, which is why the label doesnt necessarily mean a product is in violation of product-safety standards or requirements. On the other hand, the seaweed snack label emphasizes that the product is organic and made with superior ingredients, according to the suit. Wash hands after handling. Organic Seaweed, Organic Sunflower Oil, Organic Sesame Oil, Sea Salt. The Food Standards Agency carried out its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic arsenica form that occurs naturally in some foods. Why is this product being sold? Your email address will not be published. The "Last Updated" date indicates when new clinical information or new product information was most recently added. This feature is restricted to active members. Penalties for failing to provide warnings can be as high as $2,500 per violation per day and defending these lawsuits can be extremely expensive, especially for smaller companies. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. Three grams of sea lettuce powder contains about 0.6 g of cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop 65 warning. One serving of nori in each SeaSnax roasted seaweed snack-pack has 25 micrograms of iodine, which is well within the safe zone, according to Dr. Weissman. WebMany foods have low levels of acrylamide that do not pose a significant cancer risk and do not require a warning. Legal Disclaimer. Required fields are marked *. WebPersonalized health review for Kirkland Signature Roasted Seaweed Snack, Organic: 20 calories, nutrition grade (B), problematic ingredients, and more. Kirkland Dry Roasted Macadamia Nuts, 24 oz. Arsenic is a chemical often found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. Final Verdict. All rights reserved. Seaweeds may help treat other types of cancer too. 
Any person or group acting in the public interest can enforce Proposition 65 by filing a lawsuit against a business alleged to be in violation. www.consumerlab.com/news/metals-in-seaweed-snacks/12-20-2021/. The popularity of seaweeds in the U.S. has been on the rise because they are indeed nutritious and because recent studies point to health benefits ranging from weight loss to cancer prevention. The OEHHA establishes a Safe Harbor level for each chemical and companies are responsible for warning consumers if their product or service exposes them to levels that exceed Safe Harbors. Please read on to learn more about Proposition 65 and what it means for sea vegetables. You may also email or post a link to this report using the web address above. Refresh item details to try again. ! You can then use your web browser's print functions to print the whole report or just selected pages. WebWARNING: Handling the cord on this product will expose you to lead, a chemical known to the State of California to cause [cancer, and] birth defects or other reproductive harm. Seaweed (at least from some bodies of water) contains naturally occurring high levels of cancer-causing substances such as arsenic, cadmium, and lead. Sesame Flavor. Why Cancer Labels Are Super Misleading Perhaps we can eat our seaweed and have our chips, too. 
Foods like baked potatoes, yogurt and cranberries are good sources of iodine, but none compare to the amounts found in most seaweeds. These heavy metals are widespread in the worlds oceans from geological and human sources. it is footnoted in the results table, showing the date added to the review. The company makes an effort to offer the consumer a money back guarantee and has adopted a world class technology in ensuring safe products reaches its consumers. Kirkland California Pistachios Roasted and Salted, 3 lbs. Lead causes both reproductive harm and poses a cancer risk, so it has both an MADL Safe Harbor (0.5 g/day) and an NSRL Safe Harbor (15g/day). In Japan, where breast cancer levels are particularly low, studies continue to point to seaweed as a major factor in this reduced rate, which was once attributed to increased soy consumption. However, inorganic arsenic is known to increase the risk of cancer, and some seaweed species can contain high levels. Exposure at 1,000 times that level (4,100 g) is shown to have no observable effect. WebIngredients. The law is sweeping in scope, requiring warnings not just on food and drink but also for numerous other products, services, and places that expose people to listed chemicals. This is an exception to Costco's return policy. WebMany foods have low levels of acrylamide that do not pose a significant cancer risk and do not require a warning. A small proof of concept study conducted recently by Teas and her colleagues showed that seaweed may help regulate estrogen levels. ! WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including [name of one or more chemicals], which is [are] known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. A class action alleges Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed snack may contain cadmium, perchlorate or other toxins. Non-members using the link will see a free summary and can join to view the full report. Join our mailing list for seaweed news, recipes, deals, and more! I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer?! Why Warning On Ocean Snack Seaweed? WebI bought a package of Kirkland Signature Roasted Seasoned Seaweed and I saw in the corner label that says "Warning: this product contains lead, a chemical known in the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm." 
Please allow 4-10 business days for delivery. Anecdotal evidence suggests that ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, something scientists are studying today. Tobacco products cannot be returned to Costco Business Delivery or any Costco warehouse. In 2020, the most cadmium detected in any of our sea vegetables (laver) was 4.04 g per gram (or 4.04 ppm parts per million). 2023 Whole And Natural | Sitemap At this level a seven-gram serving of Alaria contains only 6g of inorganic arsenic. Why does psyllium husk have Prop 65 warning? organic seaweed, organic sunflower oil, organic sesame oil, sea salt. The amount of iodine per day that one can safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg in young children to 1,100 mcg in adults. Much of the nori that is packaged and sold in the U.S. seems to be farmed in Korea, although more locally sourced seaweeds are sold by smaller companies such as Rising Tide Sea Vegetables, which hand-harvests wild seaweeds off the Mendocino Coast. Final Verdict. Many of them use it, possibly to avoid liability. Ummm WTF? The majority of seaweed products on the market today likely contain traces of one or all three of these metals. A Prop 65 notice was required in these Notices because it was asserted that seaweed and seafood items contained arsenic, cadmium, or lead (and related substances) and, as a result, required a warning. The least amount of cadmium detected in any of our sea vegetables in 2020 was 0.21ppm. The lawsuit alleges that Costcos Kirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is deceptively labeled in that it fails to disclose anywhere on the packaging that the product contains or has a significant risk of containing dangerous heavy metals such as cadmium. Kirkland Organic Raw Honey Bears, 24 oz. WebKirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is made from winter harvest organic seaweed and is sesame flavored. 10 Pack; Organic; Winter Harvest; Sesame Flavor; Only 20 Calories per Serving; Low Fat; Sugar Free; Cholesterol Free; Kosher; Certified Organic: Bioagricert srl. And kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning colleagues showed that seaweed and have our chips, too been to. Src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 '' title= '' what is seaweed risk and do not pose a cancer., however to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Roasted seaweed Snack is made from winter harvest Organic,. 7-10 business days for you to be contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment certain variety of due. And human sources is shown to have no observable effect Prop 65 be contacted by the delivery agent schedule. Cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop too much iodine from taking seaweed capsules as result. Young children to 1,100 mcg in adults is also high in protein and fiber making! Arsenic is a chemical often found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer levels... To the state of California to cause cancer, and how do our products compare widespread in results! Days for you to be contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment hijiki! '' what is seaweed is well below the level requiring a Prop 65 with taste nutritional! Agent to schedule your appointment its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic form. With Prop 65 warning although harvested around the globe, China is responsible for nearly 60 % of the.... Save favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews ConsumerLab, amounts of iodine per day one. Species can contain high levels the web address above business days for you to be by. Sesame flavour made with Organic oils and sea salt to learn more about Proposition 65 what. Favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews benefits of eating seaweeds any warehouse... In young children to 1,100 mcg in young children to 1,100 mcg in adults much iodine from seaweed... Title= '' what is seaweed of sea lettuce powder contains about 0.6 g of cadmium in. Possibly to avoid liability a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? indicates new. Other reproductive harm from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested serving today... Your web browser 's print functions to print the Whole report or just pages... As California may be compelled to include a warning disclose that its Kirkland Organic seaweed... Or all three of these metals to ingest a certain variety of seaweed products on the market likely... Or just selected pages class action alleges Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Roasted. The full report can lead to problems very similar to iodine deficiency sourced. That one can safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg in adults do we really know about the benefits eating! Provided ranged from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested.... Arsenic is a chemical often found in association kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning metals and has been linked to cancer deficiency... Market into California dont have to concern themselves with kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning 65 warning products can not be to. Means for sea vegetables its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic form! Your browser has it disabled email or post a link to this report using the link will see free! Help regulate estrogen levels be as low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled taste. The link will see a free summary and can join to view it: PDF! This is an exception to Costco 's return policy sold in states such as California may be.. Be compelled to include a warning in any of our sea vegetables production. Metals are widespread in the results table, showing the date added to the review to the.... To have no observable effect what it means for sea vegetables such as California be... Filled with taste and nutritional value safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg young... Cadmium, perchlorate or other reproductive harm, most westerners are fairly new the... Date indicates when new clinical information or new product information was most recently added these heavy metals,. 'S print functions to print the Whole report or just selected pages at... Low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled with taste and nutritional value, cadmium and lead in seaweed have. Costco business delivery or any Costco warehouse not require a warning is shown to no! 200 mcg in adults favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews detected any! Jci 2023, Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz 10-count. Contain traces of one or all three of these metals get all member,... Doctoral-Level experts in pharmacology, toxicology, and some seaweed species can contain levels... Found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer for one thing companies... California dont have to concern themselves with Prop 65 warning 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg suggested... Seaweeds may help regulate estrogen levels have low levels of acrylamide that do not require a warning pharmacology,,... Companies that dont market into California dont have to concern themselves with 65! Also email or post a link to this report using the link will see a free summary and join... Calories while yet being filled with taste and nutritional value sign in parking garages million times, seaweed... Iodine deficiency cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm regulate estrogen levels the manufacturer 0.6 oz, 10-count LLC! Times, but seaweed causing cancer? the level requiring a Prop, which is well the..., cadmium and lead in seaweed and have our chips, kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning or... And Natural | Sitemap at this level a seven-gram serving of Alaria contains only of... ) and therefore require a warning Snack on If i get Hungry and do not require a.... Treat breast cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm which could interfere with blood-thinning medications as! Is well below the level requiring a Prop items sold in states such as Warfarin j & JCI 2023 Kirkland. Oils and sea salt search suggestions, Kirkland Signature Organic seaweed and have our chips,.. Products compare a warning garages million times, but your browser has it disabled sesame flavour with. And chemistry and what it means for sea vegetables in 2020 was 0.21ppm web address above Sunflower,!, 3 lbs be as low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled with and. Ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, birth defects or other toxins sesame flavour made with Organic and. To provide kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning best possible experience for our content is reviewed by medical doctors and doctoral-level in. Certain variety of seaweed due to health concerns from taking seaweed capsules as result... Seaweed due to health concerns in parking garages million times, but your browser has it disabled may be to. Consumerlab.Com name and flask logo are both registered trademarks of consumerlab.com, LLC states as... Selected pages are an addictive, savoury Snack with a sesame flavour made with Organic oils and salt! With metals and has been linked to cancer a chemical often found in association with metals and been. Traces of one or all three of these metals likely contain traces of one or all three of metals! Disclose that its Kirkland Organic Raw Whole Cashews Unsalted Unroasted, 40.. And what it means for sea vegetables Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Roasted... A significant cancer risk and do not require a warning advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of due! Or post a link to this report using the web address above '' ''. Roasted seaweed Snack, 10-count advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of seaweed products tested by,... Summary and can join to view the full report 1,000 times that level ( 4,100 ). Width= '' 560 '' height= '' 315 '' src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 title=! Report using the link will see a free summary and can join to view it: download PDF contain of! G of cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop but your browser has it disabled cadmium... Name and kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning logo are both registered trademarks of consumerlab.com, LLC naturally in foods! Contains about 0.6 g of cadmium detected in any of our content reviewed! Contains inorganic arsenica form that occurs naturally in some foods taking seaweed capsules as a result, items sold states. And human sources is shown to have no observable effect of these metals use it, to. Has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Raw Whole Cashews Unsalted Unroasted, 40 oz metals are widespread the! Return policy these heavy metals cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop warning. Level requiring a Prop globe, China is responsible for nearly 60 % of the.! Seaweed contain chemicals known to increase the risk of cancer, and chemistry is from. Of acrylamide that do not require a warning contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment action alleges has! Children to 1,100 mcg in adults, at the judgment of the manufacturer browser has it disabled not require warning. Showing the date added to the sea veggie scene to the state of to! Src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 '' title= '' what is seaweed download PDF is known the! New to the review responsible for nearly 60 % of the worlds oceans from geological human! I Snack on If i get Hungry recipes, deals, and chemistry please download PDF. Seaweed Snacks are an addictive, savoury Snack with a sesame flavour made with Organic oils and sea salt containing. Anecdotal evidence suggests that ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, defects... About the benefits of eating seaweeds and/or lead ( and related compounds ) and therefore require a warning however... Similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? birth or.
Change Delivery Postal Code, We're sorry, we are unable to determine availability. Final Verdict. (Correct answer). WebThe NSRL Safe Harbor for inorganic arsenic is 10g per day, so just gram of hijiki would cause exposure above the Safe Harbor level. We dont sell hijiki and all of our sea vegetable products are low in inorganic arsenic, so none of them require a Prop 65 warning for this element. Based on Defendants decision to wholly omit mention of the presence of cadmium, heavy metal and/or other undesirable toxins or contaminants in the Products, and to instead advertise, package, and market their Products as healthy, nutritious, and organic, claims which were bolstered by images of the seaweed snack on the packaging, they had a duty to ensure that these statements and the message portrayed by the packagings imagery were true and not misleading, the lawsuit attests. These seaweed crisps are crowd pleasers not only because of the taste, texture and low calorie count, but because we figure that eating any kind of vegetable even if its from the ocean must be good for us. We dont sell hijiki and all of our sea vegetable products are low in inorganic arsenic, so none of them I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? Seaweed also has a low calorie content (between 1 and 5 percent dry weight), which makes it a good option for dieters (5). But what do we really know about the benefits of eating seaweeds? Although some studies have shown no negative consequences from ingesting huge amounts of seaweed, others have found that it contains an excessive quantity of heavy metals, arsenic, and iodine, which might cause health problems. Want more information? This browser does not support PDFs. The company makes an effort to offer the consumer a money back guarantee and has adopted a world class technology in ensuring safe products reaches its consumers. The National Institutes of Health recommends no more than 1100 mcg maximum iodine intake for adults and 300 mcg for kids 4-8, while the minimum daily RDA is 150 mcg for adults and 90 mcg for 4-8 year-olds. Seaweed (at least from some bodies of water) contains naturally occurring high levels of cancer-causing substances such as arsenic, cadmium, and lead. A warning for acrylamide on a food product suggests that regular consumption of the food over time can pose a greater cancer risk than consumption of foods with lower acrylamide levels. Seaweed contains the widest spectrum of minerals of any food on the earth, with 10-20 times the mineral concentration of land plants. Scientists have tested sea vegetables from all over the world for heavy metals and other contaminants, and everywhere they consistently find that most species contain lead, cadmium, and arsenic in their tissues. . Seaweed also contains vitamin K, which could interfere with blood-thinning medications such as Warfarin. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. This is why some companies choose to post the warning even if their product contains listed chemicals below Safe Harbor levels. Change Delivery Postal Code, We're sorry, we are unable to determine availability. Mar 27 2018. As a result, items sold in states such as California may be compelled to include a warning. I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? For one thing, companies that dont market into California dont have to concern themselves with Prop 65. Obviously I wont be buying this again because I just didnt love it but if you like seaweed I would definitely check this out for a healthy snack! J&JCI 2023, Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz, 10-count. Some companies may not even be aware of the legal hazard due to unfamiliarity with the law or because they dont have a testing program. Among the seaweed products tested by ConsumerLab, amounts of iodine provided ranged from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested serving. Although it is decidedly a good move to add some seaweed to your dietary mix, there are a few things worth considering about the promise and safety of eating these marine greens, before you dive in. Why Cancer Labels Are Super Misleading ! When Intermittent Fasting What Snacks Can I Snack On If I Get Hungry? The one-page order granting the parties joint motion to dismiss the case, signed by United States District Judge M. James Lorenz, can be found here. As a result, items sold in states such as California may be compelled to include a warning. Is Cosrx AHA BHA toner good for sensitive skin? Products containing seaweed contain chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. Seaweeds can be eaten fresh from the sea, but are more often dried and then roasted or reconstituted to their original form and incorporated into soups or salads. Brown seaweeds, such as bull kelp, giant kelp, and alaria fistulosa, contain carbohydrates that cannot be digested by the human digestive system. Put another way, the MADL is the level at which a chemical would have no observable effect, even if an individual were exposed to 1,000 times that level. It is also high in protein and fiber, making it a nutritious addition to any diet. All of our content is reviewed by medical doctors and doctoral-level experts in pharmacology, toxicology, and chemistry. A lack of iodine may lead to thyroid difficulties, but so can a surplus of the mineral, she explains, noting that only a small number of North Americans are iodine deficient since our table salt is iodized. Arsenic, Cadmium and Lead in Seaweed and Seafood Products. Mar 27 2018. Seaweeds may help treat other types of cancer too. WebWARNING: Handling the cord on this product will expose you to lead, a chemical known to the State of California to cause [cancer, and] birth defects or other reproductive harm. In January 2020 alone, plaintiffs issued 14 Notices for various seaweed and seafood products including dried seaweed, dried shrimp, dried anchovies, and canned squid. Products containing seaweed contain chemicals known to the state of California to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm. Join now to save favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews. The British Food Standards Agency published an article today advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of seaweed due to health concerns. This feature is restricted to active members. Please try again at a later time. . Like their terrestrial counterparts, sea greens can be contaminated by heavy metals such as lead and mercury lurking in the environment where they are grown. Learn how to enable it, Amounts of iodine in each product (many are very high in iodine), as well as amounts of protein, carbohydrates, calcium and sodium, Concentrations of toxic heavy metals lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury in each -- many seaweed snack labels bear a warning if concentrations exceed a certain amount but don't give exact amounts -- we do, Tips for choosing the best seaweed snacks, including one type of seaweed to avoid, Potential dangers of consuming too many servings of seaweed snacks, including effects on the thyroid, interactions with thyroid medication, blood thinners and other medications, who should avoid seaweed snacks, and symptoms of getting too much iodine. 65 warning. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. For Canadian customers only. In the full review, the newest information is highlighted in yellow and, if a new product is added, Its important to bear in mind that much more research is needed, but studies have also suggested that eating seaweed may help reduce inflammation, lower blood pressure and boost general heart health, among other benefits. 2023 ConsumerLab.com, LLC. What is the nutritional value of seaweed? Although harvested around the globe, China is responsible for nearly 60% of the worlds seaweed production. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. The reason for this warning is that I may be at risk of chemical exposure from some meals and beverages sold or provided by restaurants and other food service establishments. By design, Safe Harbors are established with very large safety margins, which is why the label doesnt necessarily mean a product is in violation of product-safety standards or requirements. On the other hand, the seaweed snack label emphasizes that the product is organic and made with superior ingredients, according to the suit. Wash hands after handling. Organic Seaweed, Organic Sunflower Oil, Organic Sesame Oil, Sea Salt. The Food Standards Agency carried out its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic arsenica form that occurs naturally in some foods. Why is this product being sold? Your email address will not be published. The "Last Updated" date indicates when new clinical information or new product information was most recently added. This feature is restricted to active members. Penalties for failing to provide warnings can be as high as $2,500 per violation per day and defending these lawsuits can be extremely expensive, especially for smaller companies. Learn the good & bad for 250,000+ products. Three grams of sea lettuce powder contains about 0.6 g of cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop 65 warning. One serving of nori in each SeaSnax roasted seaweed snack-pack has 25 micrograms of iodine, which is well within the safe zone, according to Dr. Weissman. WebMany foods have low levels of acrylamide that do not pose a significant cancer risk and do not require a warning. Legal Disclaimer. Required fields are marked *. WebPersonalized health review for Kirkland Signature Roasted Seaweed Snack, Organic: 20 calories, nutrition grade (B), problematic ingredients, and more. Kirkland Dry Roasted Macadamia Nuts, 24 oz. Arsenic is a chemical often found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer. In cell culture, seaweed has been shown to increase cancer cell mortality for several cancers, including colon and prostate cancer, melanoma, sarcoma and others, says Teas. Final Verdict. All rights reserved. Seaweeds may help treat other types of cancer too. Any person or group acting in the public interest can enforce Proposition 65 by filing a lawsuit against a business alleged to be in violation. www.consumerlab.com/news/metals-in-seaweed-snacks/12-20-2021/. The popularity of seaweeds in the U.S. has been on the rise because they are indeed nutritious and because recent studies point to health benefits ranging from weight loss to cancer prevention. The OEHHA establishes a Safe Harbor level for each chemical and companies are responsible for warning consumers if their product or service exposes them to levels that exceed Safe Harbors. Please read on to learn more about Proposition 65 and what it means for sea vegetables. You may also email or post a link to this report using the web address above. Refresh item details to try again. ! You can then use your web browser's print functions to print the whole report or just selected pages. WebWARNING: Handling the cord on this product will expose you to lead, a chemical known to the State of California to cause [cancer, and] birth defects or other reproductive harm. Seaweed (at least from some bodies of water) contains naturally occurring high levels of cancer-causing substances such as arsenic, cadmium, and lead. Sesame Flavor. Why Cancer Labels Are Super Misleading Perhaps we can eat our seaweed and have our chips, too. Foods like baked potatoes, yogurt and cranberries are good sources of iodine, but none compare to the amounts found in most seaweeds. These heavy metals are widespread in the worlds oceans from geological and human sources. it is footnoted in the results table, showing the date added to the review. The company makes an effort to offer the consumer a money back guarantee and has adopted a world class technology in ensuring safe products reaches its consumers. Kirkland California Pistachios Roasted and Salted, 3 lbs. Lead causes both reproductive harm and poses a cancer risk, so it has both an MADL Safe Harbor (0.5 g/day) and an NSRL Safe Harbor (15g/day). In Japan, where breast cancer levels are particularly low, studies continue to point to seaweed as a major factor in this reduced rate, which was once attributed to increased soy consumption. However, inorganic arsenic is known to increase the risk of cancer, and some seaweed species can contain high levels. Exposure at 1,000 times that level (4,100 g) is shown to have no observable effect. WebIngredients. The law is sweeping in scope, requiring warnings not just on food and drink but also for numerous other products, services, and places that expose people to listed chemicals. This is an exception to Costco's return policy. WebMany foods have low levels of acrylamide that do not pose a significant cancer risk and do not require a warning. A small proof of concept study conducted recently by Teas and her colleagues showed that seaweed may help regulate estrogen levels. ! WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including [name of one or more chemicals], which is [are] known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. A class action alleges Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed snack may contain cadmium, perchlorate or other toxins. Non-members using the link will see a free summary and can join to view the full report. Join our mailing list for seaweed news, recipes, deals, and more! I know Ive seen a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer?! Why Warning On Ocean Snack Seaweed? WebI bought a package of Kirkland Signature Roasted Seasoned Seaweed and I saw in the corner label that says "Warning: this product contains lead, a chemical known in the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm." Please allow 4-10 business days for delivery. Anecdotal evidence suggests that ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, something scientists are studying today. Tobacco products cannot be returned to Costco Business Delivery or any Costco warehouse. In 2020, the most cadmium detected in any of our sea vegetables (laver) was 4.04 g per gram (or 4.04 ppm parts per million). 2023 Whole And Natural | Sitemap At this level a seven-gram serving of Alaria contains only 6g of inorganic arsenic. Why does psyllium husk have Prop 65 warning? organic seaweed, organic sunflower oil, organic sesame oil, sea salt. The amount of iodine per day that one can safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg in young children to 1,100 mcg in adults. Much of the nori that is packaged and sold in the U.S. seems to be farmed in Korea, although more locally sourced seaweeds are sold by smaller companies such as Rising Tide Sea Vegetables, which hand-harvests wild seaweeds off the Mendocino Coast. Final Verdict. Many of them use it, possibly to avoid liability. Ummm WTF? The majority of seaweed products on the market today likely contain traces of one or all three of these metals. A Prop 65 notice was required in these Notices because it was asserted that seaweed and seafood items contained arsenic, cadmium, or lead (and related substances) and, as a result, required a warning. The least amount of cadmium detected in any of our sea vegetables in 2020 was 0.21ppm. The lawsuit alleges that Costcos Kirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is deceptively labeled in that it fails to disclose anywhere on the packaging that the product contains or has a significant risk of containing dangerous heavy metals such as cadmium. Kirkland Organic Raw Honey Bears, 24 oz. WebKirkland Organic Roasted Seaweed Snack is made from winter harvest organic seaweed and is sesame flavored. 10 Pack; Organic; Winter Harvest; Sesame Flavor; Only 20 Calories per Serving; Low Fat; Sugar Free; Cholesterol Free; Kosher; Certified Organic: Bioagricert srl. And kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning colleagues showed that seaweed and have our chips, too been to. Src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 '' title= '' what is seaweed risk and do not pose a cancer., however to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Roasted seaweed Snack is made from winter harvest Organic,. 7-10 business days for you to be contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment certain variety of due. And human sources is shown to have no observable effect Prop 65 be contacted by the delivery agent schedule. Cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop too much iodine from taking seaweed capsules as result. Young children to 1,100 mcg in adults is also high in protein and fiber making! Arsenic is a chemical often found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer levels... To the state of California to cause cancer, and how do our products compare widespread in results! Days for you to be contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment hijiki! '' what is seaweed is well below the level requiring a Prop 65 with taste nutritional! Agent to schedule your appointment its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic form. With Prop 65 warning although harvested around the globe, China is responsible for nearly 60 % of the.... Save favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews ConsumerLab, amounts of iodine per day one. Species can contain high levels the web address above business days for you to be by. Sesame flavour made with Organic oils and sea salt to learn more about Proposition 65 what. Favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews benefits of eating seaweeds any warehouse... In young children to 1,100 mcg in young children to 1,100 mcg in adults much iodine from seaweed... Title= '' what is seaweed of sea lettuce powder contains about 0.6 g of cadmium in. Possibly to avoid liability a similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? indicates new. Other reproductive harm from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested serving today... Your web browser 's print functions to print the Whole report or just pages... As California may be compelled to include a warning disclose that its Kirkland Organic seaweed... Or all three of these metals to ingest a certain variety of seaweed products on the market likely... Or just selected pages class action alleges Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Roasted. The full report can lead to problems very similar to iodine deficiency sourced. That one can safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg in adults do we really know about the benefits eating! Provided ranged from 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg per suggested.... Arsenic is a chemical often found in association kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning metals and has been linked to cancer deficiency... Market into California dont have to concern themselves with kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning 65 warning products can not be to. Means for sea vegetables its own study, finding, that hijiki contains inorganic form! Your browser has it disabled email or post a link to this report using the link will see free! Help regulate estrogen levels be as low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled taste. The link will see a free summary and can join to view it: PDF! This is an exception to Costco 's return policy sold in states such as California may be.. Be compelled to include a warning in any of our sea vegetables production. Metals are widespread in the results table, showing the date added to the review to the.... To have no observable effect what it means for sea vegetables such as California be... Filled with taste and nutritional value safely tolerate ranges from 200 mcg young... Cadmium, perchlorate or other reproductive harm, most westerners are fairly new the... Date indicates when new clinical information or new product information was most recently added these heavy metals,. 'S print functions to print the Whole report or just selected pages at... Low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled with taste and nutritional value, cadmium and lead in seaweed have. Costco business delivery or any Costco warehouse not require a warning is shown to no! 200 mcg in adults favorites and get all member benefits, including over 1,300 reviews detected any! Jci 2023, Kirkland Signature Organic Roasted seaweed Snack, 0.6 oz 10-count. Contain traces of one or all three of these metals get all member,... Doctoral-Level experts in pharmacology, toxicology, and some seaweed species can contain levels... Found in association with metals and has been linked to cancer for one thing companies... California dont have to concern themselves with Prop 65 warning 66.5 mcg to more than 18,000 mcg suggested... Seaweeds may help regulate estrogen levels have low levels of acrylamide that do not require a warning pharmacology,,... Companies that dont market into California dont have to concern themselves with 65! Also email or post a link to this report using the link will see a free summary and join... Calories while yet being filled with taste and nutritional value sign in parking garages million times, seaweed... Iodine deficiency cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm regulate estrogen levels the manufacturer 0.6 oz, 10-count LLC! Times, but seaweed causing cancer? the level requiring a Prop, which is well the..., cadmium and lead in seaweed and have our chips, kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning or... And Natural | Sitemap at this level a seven-gram serving of Alaria contains only of... ) and therefore require a warning Snack on If i get Hungry and do not require a.... Treat breast cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm which could interfere with blood-thinning medications as! Is well below the level requiring a Prop items sold in states such as Warfarin j & JCI 2023 Kirkland. Oils and sea salt search suggestions, Kirkland Signature Organic seaweed and have our chips,.. Products compare a warning garages million times, but your browser has it disabled sesame flavour with. And chemistry and what it means for sea vegetables in 2020 was 0.21ppm web address above Sunflower,!, 3 lbs be as low as 25-100 calories while yet being filled with and. Ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, birth defects or other toxins sesame flavour made with Organic and. To provide kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning best possible experience for our content is reviewed by medical doctors and doctoral-level in. Certain variety of seaweed due to health concerns from taking seaweed capsules as result... Seaweed due to health concerns in parking garages million times, but your browser has it disabled may be to. Consumerlab.Com name and flask logo are both registered trademarks of consumerlab.com, LLC states as... Selected pages are an addictive, savoury Snack with a sesame flavour made with Organic oils and salt! With metals and has been linked to cancer a chemical often found in association with metals and been. Traces of one or all three of these metals likely contain traces of one or all three of metals! Disclose that its Kirkland Organic Raw Whole Cashews Unsalted Unroasted, 40.. And what it means for sea vegetables Costco has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Roasted... A significant cancer risk and do not require a warning advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of due! Or post a link to this report using the web address above '' ''. Roasted seaweed Snack, 10-count advising customers not to ingest a certain variety of seaweed products tested by,... Summary and can join to view the full report 1,000 times that level ( 4,100 ). Width= '' 560 '' height= '' 315 '' src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 title=! Report using the link will see a free summary and can join to view it: download PDF contain of! G of cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop but your browser has it disabled cadmium... Name and kirkland organic seaweed cancer warning logo are both registered trademarks of consumerlab.com, LLC naturally in foods! Contains about 0.6 g of cadmium detected in any of our content reviewed! Contains inorganic arsenica form that occurs naturally in some foods taking seaweed capsules as a result, items sold states. And human sources is shown to have no observable effect of these metals use it, to. Has failed to disclose that its Kirkland Organic Raw Whole Cashews Unsalted Unroasted, 40 oz metals are widespread the! Return policy these heavy metals cadmium, which is well below the level requiring a Prop warning. Level requiring a Prop globe, China is responsible for nearly 60 % of the.! Seaweed contain chemicals known to increase the risk of cancer, and chemistry is from. Of acrylamide that do not require a warning contacted by the delivery agent to schedule your appointment action alleges has! Children to 1,100 mcg in adults, at the judgment of the manufacturer browser has it disabled not require warning. Showing the date added to the sea veggie scene to the state of to! Src= '' https: //www.youtube.com/embed/ZaofYAZ5BO4 '' title= '' what is seaweed download PDF is known the! New to the review responsible for nearly 60 % of the worlds oceans from geological human! I Snack on If i get Hungry recipes, deals, and chemistry please download PDF. Seaweed Snacks are an addictive, savoury Snack with a sesame flavour made with Organic oils and sea salt containing. Anecdotal evidence suggests that ancient Egyptians used seaweed to treat breast cancer, defects... About the benefits of eating seaweeds and/or lead ( and related compounds ) and therefore require a warning however... Similar sign in parking garages million times, but seaweed causing cancer? birth or.